Skip to main content

Fresh mozzarella and homemade sandwiches made by hand every day.

Call to order: (631) 653-8071

Catering

Feed the Party

family recipes, by the tray.

We cater parties and events with old-fashioned Italian staples, made from family recipes handed down for generations. Trays come in medium and large.

Call to plan your order Back to home
A round tray piled with large homemade meatballs
Hands rolling out dough with a wooden rolling pin on a floured steel table
Rolled out by hand.

Parties & events

The food you grew up on, by the tray.

Lasagna, baked ziti, chicken cutlet parm, eggplant rollatini, sausage & peppers and heros by the foot. The same family recipes we make for our own table.

Not sure what to get? Ask for suggestions! Tell us the occasion and we'll help you build the spread.

Call to plan your order

From the kitchen

A few more things we make.

  • A rice ball split open to show the cheese and filling, in tomato sauce

    Rice balls

  • A rice ball topped with tomato sauce and grated cheese on a small plate

    Rice balls, with sauce

  • Two loaves of salami bread sliced open to show the salami, cheese and peppers rolled inside

    Salami bread

  • Two thick burger patties searing on a grill over open flame

    Burgers

How catering works

One phone call.

Tell us about the party and we'll take it from there.

A rainbow cookie held up in front of the Village Prime storefront in the snow

  1. Step 1: Call the counter

    Call (631) 653-8071, or ask at the counter.

  2. Step 2: Date & headcount

    Tell us the date, the occasion and how many people.

  3. Step 3: We recommend trays

    We'll suggest the trays and sizes for your crowd.

  4. Step 4: Pick it up

    Come by the shop and pick it up, ready to set out.

Party ideas

A few spreads to start from.

Mix and match from the menu. Ask us how many each tray feeds and we'll size it to your headcount.

  • The Sunday table

    • Baked ZitiM $70 · L $125
    • Chicken Cutlet ParmM $90 · L $160
    • Italian Hero by the foot$31.99/ft

  • Something for everyone

    • Meat LasagnaM $80 · L $150
    • Vegetable LasagnaM $75 · L $150
    • Eggplant RollatiniM $80 · L $160
    • Roasted Vegetables$13.99/lb

  • Game day

    • Buffalo WingsM $75 · L $140
    • BBQ Chicken WingsM $75 · L $140
    • American Hero by the foot$26.99/ft
    • Macaroni & CheeseM $65 · L $115

  • Old-school Italian

    • Sausage & PeppersM $80 · L $160
    • Meatballs$12.99/lb
    • Eggplant ParmesanM $80 · L $160
    • Baked Stuffed ShellsM $70 · L $125
Ask us how many each tray feeds.Tell us your headcount and we'll recommend the sizes.
A golden fried rice ball on a white plate
Rice balls, fried fresh.

Not a party?

Prepared foods, made fresh daily.

We also make prepared foods fresh every day. The eggplant parm and the roasted peppers are local favorites.

  • Turkey Pot Pie$13.99 ea
  • Chicken Pot Pie$13.99 ea
  • Eggplant Parmesan$10.99/lb

Seafood (shrimp, crab cakes) is priced seasonally. Call for today's price.

While you're here

Also at the counter

  • Butcher

    All prime, cut to order at the counter.

  • Sandwiches

    9 sandwiches, cutlets made fresh.

  • Market

    Oils, pastas, cheeses, pies and more.

  • About

    A family-run Italian butcher at the light.

Planning a party? Call the counter.

Tell us the date, the occasion and how many you're feeding. Call (631) 653-8071 and we'll put the spread together.

Call to Order · (631) 653-8071Get Directions
495 Montauk Highway, East QuogueTue–Sat 9–6 · Sun 9–4 · Closed Mon